[Bug]合并转发消息中，bot发送的内容不可见

[Yangyuwuhan]

What happened / 发生了什么

对于使用QQ个人号部署的机器人，试图发送含有bot消息的“合并转发”消息给bot时，转发消息内的bot消息对bot不可见

Reproduce / 如何复现？

发送含有bot消息的“合并转发”消息，在私聊/群聊中引用该“合并转发”消息并触发bot，结果bot只能看到不属于bot的消息

注：经检查，确认已经关闭“是否忽略机器人自身的消息”

AstrBot version, deployment method (e.g., Windows Docker Desktop deployment), provider used, and messaging platform used. / AstrBot 版本、部署方式（如 Windows Docker Desktop 部署）、使用的提供商、使用的消息平台适配器

v4.25.3、linux uv部署、deepseekV4f、aiocqhttp

OS

Linux

Logs / 报错日志

聊天记录：

通过webUI查找的对话记录：

Are you willing to submit a PR? / 你愿意提交 PR 吗？

• Yes!

Code of Conduct

• I have read and agree to abide by the project's Code of Conduct。

[dosubot]

看了一下相关代码，问题出在合并转发消息的引用解析逻辑中。

在 chain_parser.py 的 _extract_text_forward_ids_and_images_from_forward_nodes() 函数中 [1]，解析转发节点时会遍历所有 node 并提取 sender 和 message 内容，但这里没有任何基于发送者身份的过滤逻辑——所有节点理论上都会被处理。

而"忽略机器人自身的消息"设置只作用于顶层消息事件的 pipeline 阶段 [2]，不会影响转发节点内部的解析。

因此可能的原因是：

1. 虽然你关闭了"忽略机器人自身的消息"，但可能还有其他过滤环节在转发节点解析之前或之后丢弃了 bot 发送的节点内容。
2. 或者是 OneBot 实现端（如 NapCat/Lagrange 等）在返回 get_forward_msg 时，本身就没有返回 bot 自己发送的消息节点。

建议你检查一下：

• 在 bot 收到转发消息时，打印实际从 OneBot 端获取到的转发消息原始数据（get_forward_msg 的返回结果），看看 bot 的消息节点是否存在于原始数据中。
• 如果原始数据中就缺失，那这是 OneBot 实现端的问题，而非 AstrBot 的问题。

To reply, just mention @dosu.

---

Docs are dead. Just use Dosu.

[Yangyuwuhan]

@dosu
NapCat端调试日志如下，正常解析了合并转发消息中bot自身的消息

[INFO] 接收 <- 群聊 [拾遗者(700272298)] [羊羽无寒(2017759319)] [转发消息]
[DEBUG] 收到新消息 RawMessage {"msgId":"7653847700138823685","msgRandom":"1816370878","msgSeq":"17345","cntSeq":"0","chatType":2,"msgType":8,"subMsgType":0,"sendType":0,"senderUid":"u_5wWnyCTLNn9A-Q_CxGeVyA","peerUid":"700272298","channelId":"","guildId":"","guildCode":"0","fromUid":"0","fromAppid":"0","msgTime":"1782050286","msgMeta":{},"sendStatus":2,"sendRemarkName":"羊羽无寒","sendMemberName":"羊羽无寒","sendNickName":"","guildName":"","channelName":"","elements":[{"elementType":16,"elementId":"7653847700138823684","elementGroupId":0,"extBufForUI":{},"textElement":null,"faceElement":null,"marketFaceElement":null,"replyElement":null,"picElement":null,"pttElement":null,"videoElement":null,"grayTipElement":null,"arkElement":null,"fileElement":null,"liveGiftElement":null,"markdownElement":null,"structLongMsgElement":null,"multiForwardMsgElement":{"xmlContent":"<?xml version='1.0' encoding='UTF-8' standalone=\"yes\"?> <msg serviceID=\"35\" templateID=\"1\" action=\"viewMultiMsg\" brief=\"[聊天记录]\" m_fileName=\"590af1f0-e6b1-44ab-bff0-1513c78c4ad8\" m_resid=\"Y9XWzpl/gHjyh325RGSPbTDKYuU9kyEDIPbikaQB8ihVvBj7qy7WcFrLhmQ+sZo+\" tSum=\"3\" flag=\"3\"><item layout=\"1\"> <title color=\"#000000\" size=\"34\">飞翔和有曦的聊天记录</title><title color=\"#777777\" size=\"26\">飞翔: 妹妹我失眠了</title><title color=\"#777777\" size=\"26\">有曦: 哥都两点了！</title><title color=\"#777777\" size=\"26\">有曦: 你明天还要考口语呢，赶紧闭上眼睛深呼吸，我...","resId":"Y9XWzpl/gHjyh325RGSPbTDKYuU9kyEDIPbikaQB8ihVvBj7qy7WcFrLhmQ+sZo+","fileName":"590af1f0-e6b1-44ab-bff0-1513c78c4ad8"},"giphyElement":null,"walletElement":null,"inlineKeyboardElement":null,"textGiftElement":null,"calendarElement":null,"yoloGameResultElement":null,"avRecordElement":null,"structMsgElement":null,"faceBubbleElement":null,"shareLocationElement":null,"tofuRecordElement":null,"taskTopMsgElement":null,"recommendedMsgElement":null,"actionBarElement":null,"prologueMsgElement":null,"forwardMsgElement":null}],"auxiliaryElements":[],"records":[],"emojiLikesList":[],"commentCnt":"0","directMsgFlag":0,"directMsgMembers":[],"peerName":"拾遗者","freqLimitInfo":null,"editable":false,"avatarMeta":"","avatarPendant":"","feedId":"","roleId":"0","timeStamp":"0","clientIdentityInfo":null,"isImportMsg":false,"atType":0,"roleType":0,"fromChannelRoleInfo":{"roleId":"0","name":"","color":0},"fromGuildRoleInfo":{"roleId":"0","name":"","color":0},"levelRoleInfo":{"roleId":"0","name":"","color":0},"recallTime":"0","isOnlineMsg":true,"generalFlags":{},"clientSeq":"0","fileGroupSize":null,"foldingInfo":null,"multiTransInfo":null,"senderUin":"2017759319","peerUin":"700272298","msgAttrs":{},"anonymousExtInfo":null,"nameType":0,"avatarFlag":0,"extInfoForUI":null,"personalMedal":null,"categoryManage":0,"msgEventInfo":null,"sourceType":1,"id":144527672}
[DEBUG] [Core] [Packet] rawChains ,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
[DEBUG] 转化为 OB11Message {"stringMsg":{"self_id":3642941266,"user_id":2017759319,"time":1782050286,"message_id":144527672,"message_seq":144527672,"real_id":144527672,"real_seq":"17345","message_type":"group","sender":{"user_id":2017759319,"nickname":"飞翔","card":"羊羽无寒","role":"owner"},"raw_message":"[CQ:forward,id=7653847700138823685]","font":14,"sub_type":"normal","message":"[CQ:forward,id=7653847700138823685]","message_format":"string","post_type":"message","group_id":700272298,"group_name":"拾遗者"},"arrayMsg":{"self_id":3642941266,"user_id":2017759319,"time":1782050286,"message_id":144527672,"message_seq":144527672,"real_id":144527672,"real_seq":"17345","message_type":"group","sender":{"user_id":2017759319,"nickname":"飞翔","card":"羊羽无寒","role":"owner"},"raw_message":"[CQ:forward,id=7653847700138823685]","font":14,"sub_type":"normal","message":[{"type":"forward","data":{"id":"7653847700138823685"}}],"message_format":"array","post_type":"message","group_id":700272298,"group_name":"拾遗者"}}
[INFO] 接收 <- 群聊 [拾遗者(700272298)] [羊羽无寒(2017759319)] [回复消息 [羊羽无寒(2017759319)] [转发消息]] @有曦 (3642941266)  妹妹看看这段对话说了什么
[DEBUG] 收到新消息 RawMessage {"msgId":"7653847764147188174","msgRandom":"1170113731","msgSeq":"17346","cntSeq":"0","chatType":2,"msgType":9,"subMsgType":33,"sendType":0,"senderUid":"u_5wWnyCTLNn9A-Q_CxGeVyA","peerUid":"700272298","channelId":"","guildId":"","guildCode":"0","fromUid":"0","fromAppid":"0","msgTime":"1782050301","msgMeta":{},"sendStatus":2,"sendRemarkName":"羊羽无寒","sendMemberName":"羊羽无寒","sendNickName":"","guildName":"","channelName":"","elements":[{"elementType":7,"elementId":"7653847764147188166","elementGroupId":0,"extBufForUI":{},"textElement":null,"faceElement":null,"marketFaceElement":null,"replyElement":{"replayMsgId":"0","replayMsgSeq":"17345","replayMsgRootSeq":"0","replayMsgRootMsgId":"0","replayMsgRootCommentCnt":"0","sourceMsgIdInRecords":"7653847764147188178","sourceMsgText":"","sourceMsgTextElems":[{"replyAbsElemType":1,"textElemContent":"[聊天记录]","faceElem":null,"picElem":null}],"senderUid":"2017759319","senderUidStr":"u_5wWnyCTLNn9A-Q_CxGeVyA","replyMsgClientSeq":"0","replyMsgTime":"1782050286","replyMsgRevokeType":0,"sourceMsgIsIncPic":false,"sourceMsgExpired":false,"anonymousNickName":null,"originalMsgState":null},"picElement":null,"pttElement":null,"videoElement":null,"grayTipElement":null,"arkElement":null,"fileElement":null,"liveGiftElement":null,"markdownElement":null,"structLongMsgElement":null,"multiForwardMsgElement":null,"giphyElement":null,"walletElement":null,"inlineKeyboardElement":null,"textGiftElement":null,"calendarElement":null,"yoloGameResultElement":null,"avRecordElement":null,"structMsgElement":null,"faceBubbleElement":null,"shareLocationElement":null,"tofuRecordElement":null,"taskTopMsgElement":null,"recommendedMsgElement":null,"actionBarElement":null,"prologueMsgElement":null,"forwardMsgElement":null},{"elementType":1,"elementId":"7653847764147188172","elementGroupId":0,"extBufForUI":{},"textElement":{"content":"@有曦","atType":2,"atUid":"3642941266","atTinyId":"0","atNtUid":"u_tQWiJuiY1HS4CjZzM-aVjw","subElementType":0,"atChannelId":"0","linkInfo":null,"atRoleId":"0","atRoleColor":0,"atRoleName":"","needNotify":0},"faceElement":null,"marketFaceElement":null,"replyElement":null,"picElement":null,"pttElement":null,"videoElement":null,"grayTipElement":null,"arkElement":null,"fileElement":null,"liveGiftElement":null,"markdownElement":null,"structLongMsgElement":null,"multiForwardMsgElement":null,"giphyElement":null,"walletElement":null,"inlineKeyboardElement":null,"textGiftElement":null,"calendarElement":null,"yoloGameResultElement":null,"avRecordElement":null,"structMsgElement":null,"faceBubbleElement":null,"shareLocationElement":null,"tofuRecordElement":null,"taskTopMsgElement":null,"recommendedMsgElement":null,"actionBarElement":null,"prologueMsgElement":null,"forwardMsgElement":null},{"elementType":1,"elementId":"7653847764147188173","elementGroupId":0,"extBufForUI":{},"textElement":{"content":" 妹妹看看这段对话说了什么","atType":0,"atUid":"0","atTinyId":"0","atNtUid":"","subElementType":0,"atChannelId":"0","linkInfo":null,"atRoleId":"0","atRoleColor":0,"atRoleName":"","needNotify":0},"faceElement":null,"marketFaceElement":null,"replyElement":null,"picElement":null,"pttElement":null,"videoElement":null,"grayTipElement":null,"arkElement":null,"fileElement":null,"liveGiftElement":null,"markdownElement":null,"structLongMsgElement":null,"multiForwardMsgElement":null,"giphyElement":null,"walletElement":null,"inlineKeyboardElement":null,"textGiftElement":null,"calendarElement":null,"yoloGameResultElement":null,"avRecordElement":null,"structMsgElement":null,"faceBubbleElement":null,"shareLocationElement":null,"tofuRecordElement":null,"taskTopMsgElement":null,"recommendedMsgElement":null,"actionBarElement":null,"prologueMsgElement":null,"forwardMsgElement":null}],"auxiliaryElements":[],"records":[{"msgId":"7653847764147188178","msgRandom":"1816370878","msgSeq":"17345","cntSeq":"0","chatType":2,"msgType":8,"subMsgType":0,"sendType":0,"senderUid":"u_5wWnyCTLNn9A-Q_CxGeVyA","peerUid":"700272298","channelId":"","guildId":"","guildCode":"0","fromUid":"0","fromAppid":"0","msgTime":"1782050286","msgMeta":{},"sendStatus":2,"sendRemarkName":"羊羽无寒","sendMemberName":"羊羽无寒","sendNickName":"飞翔","guildName":"","channelName":"","elements":[{"elementType":16,"elementId":"7653847764147188182","elementGroupId":0,"extBufForUI":{},"textElement":null,"faceElement":null,"marketFaceElement":null,"replyElement":null,"picElement":null,"pttElement":null,"videoElement":null,"grayTipElement":null,"arkElement":null,"fileElement":null,"liveGiftElement":null,"markdownElement":null,"structLongMsgElement":null,"multiForwardMsgElement":{"xmlContent":"<?xml version='1.0' encoding='UTF-8' standalone=\"yes\"?> <msg serviceID=\"35\" templateID=\"1\" action=\"viewMultiMsg\" brief=\"[聊天记录]\" m_fileName=\"590af1f0-e6b1-44ab-bff0-1513c78c4ad8\" m_resid=\"Y9XWzpl/gHjyh325RGSPbTDKYuU9kyEDIPbikaQB8ihVvBj7qy7WcFrLhmQ+sZo+\" tSum=\"3\" flag=\"3\"><item layout=\"1\"> <title color=\"#000000\" size=\"34\">飞翔和有曦的聊天记录</title><title color=\"#777777\" size=\"26\">飞翔: 妹妹我失眠了</title><title color=\"#777777\" size=\"26\">有曦: 哥都两点了！</title><title color=\"#777777\" size=\"26\">有曦: 你明天还要考口语呢，赶紧闭上眼睛深呼吸，我...","resId":"Y9XWzpl/gHjyh325RGSPbTDKYuU9kyEDIPbikaQB8ihVvBj7qy7WcFrLhmQ+sZo+","fileName":"590af1f0-e6b1-44ab-bff0-1513c78c4ad8"},"giphyElement":null,"walletElement":null,"inlineKeyboardElement":null,"textGiftElement":null,"calendarElement":null,"yoloGameResultElement":null,"avRecordElement":null,"structMsgElement":null,"faceBubbleElement":null,"shareLocationElement":null,"tofuRecordElement":null,"taskTopMsgElement":null,"recommendedMsgElement":null,"actionBarElement":null,"prologueMsgElement":null,"forwardMsgElement":null}],"auxiliaryElements":[],"records":[],"emojiLikesList":[],"commentCnt":"0","directMsgFlag":0,"directMsgMembers":[],"peerName":"拾遗者","freqLimitInfo":null,"editable":false,"avatarMeta":"","avatarPendant":"","feedId":"","roleId":"0","timeStamp":"0","clientIdentityInfo":null,"isImportMsg":false,"atType":0,"roleType":0,"fromChannelRoleInfo":{"roleId":"0","name":"","color":0},"fromGuildRoleInfo":{"roleId":"0","name":"","color":0},"levelRoleInfo":{"roleId":"0","name":"","color":0},"recallTime":"0","isOnlineMsg":false,"generalFlags":{},"clientSeq":"0","fileGroupSize":null,"foldingInfo":null,"multiTransInfo":null,"senderUin":"2017759319","peerUin":"700272298","msgAttrs":{},"anonymousExtInfo":null,"nameType":0,"avatarFlag":0,"extInfoForUI":null,"personalMedal":null,"categoryManage":0,"msgEventInfo":null,"sourceType":0}],"emojiLikesList":[],"commentCnt":"0","directMsgFlag":0,"directMsgMembers":[],"peerName":"拾遗者","freqLimitInfo":null,"editable":false,"avatarMeta":"","avatarPendant":"","feedId":"","roleId":"0","timeStamp":"0","clientIdentityInfo":null,"isImportMsg":false,"atType":6,"roleType":0,"fromChannelRoleInfo":{"roleId":"0","name":"","color":0},"fromGuildRoleInfo":{"roleId":"0","name":"","color":0},"levelRoleInfo":{"roleId":"0","name":"","color":0},"recallTime":"0","isOnlineMsg":true,"generalFlags":{},"clientSeq":"0","fileGroupSize":null,"foldingInfo":null,"multiTransInfo":null,"senderUin":"2017759319","peerUin":"700272298","msgAttrs":{},"anonymousExtInfo":null,"nameType":0,"avatarFlag":0,"extInfoForUI":null,"personalMedal":null,"categoryManage":0,"msgEventInfo":null,"sourceType":1,"id":815782659}
[DEBUG] 转化为 OB11Message {"stringMsg":{"self_id":3642941266,"user_id":2017759319,"time":1782050301,"message_id":815782659,"message_seq":815782659,"real_id":815782659,"real_seq":"17346","message_type":"group","sender":{"user_id":2017759319,"nickname":"飞翔","card":"羊羽无寒","role":"owner"},"raw_message":"[CQ:reply,id=144527672][CQ:at,qq=3642941266] 妹妹看看这段对话说了什么","font":14,"sub_type":"normal","message":"[CQ:reply,id=144527672][CQ:at,qq=3642941266] 妹妹看看这段对话说了什么","message_format":"string","post_type":"message","group_id":700272298,"group_name":"拾遗者"},"arrayMsg":{"self_id":3642941266,"user_id":2017759319,"time":1782050301,"message_id":815782659,"message_seq":815782659,"real_id":815782659,"real_seq":"17346","message_type":"group","sender":{"user_id":2017759319,"nickname":"飞翔","card":"羊羽无寒","role":"owner"},"raw_message":"[CQ:reply,id=144527672][CQ:at,qq=3642941266] 妹妹看看这段对话说了什么","font":14,"sub_type":"normal","message":[{"type":"reply","data":{"id":"144527672"}},{"type":"at","data":{"qq":"3642941266"}},{"type":"text","data":{"text":" 妹妹看看这段对话说了什么"}}],"message_format":"array","post_type":"message","group_id":700272298,"group_name":"拾遗者"}}
[DEBUG] [OneBot] [WebSocket Client] 收到正向Websocket消息 {"action":"get_msg","params":{"message_id":144527672},"echo":{"seq":620}}
[DEBUG] [OneBot] [WebSocket Client] 收到正向Websocket消息 {"action":"get_group_member_info","params":{"group_id":700272298,"user_id":3642941266,"no_cache":false},"echo":{"seq":622}}
[DEBUG] [OneBot] [WebSocket Client] 收到正向Websocket消息 {"action":"get_stranger_info","params":{"user_id":3642941266,"no_cache":false},"echo":{"seq":624}}
[DEBUG] [OneBot] [WebSocket Client] 收到正向Websocket消息 {"action":"get_msg","params":{"message_id":"144527672"},"echo":{"seq":626}}
[DEBUG] [OneBot] [WebSocket Client] 收到正向Websocket消息 {"action":"get_forward_msg","params":{"message_id":"7653847700138823685"},"echo":{"seq":627}}
[DEBUG] [OneBot] [WebSocket Client] 收到正向Websocket消息 {"action":"get_msg","params":{"message_id":"144527672"},"echo":{"seq":628}}
[DEBUG] [OneBot] [WebSocket Client] 收到正向Websocket消息 {"action":"get_forward_msg","params":{"message_id":"7653847700138823685"},"echo":{"seq":629}}
[DEBUG] [OneBot] [WebSocket Client] 收到正向Websocket消息 {"action":"send_group_msg","params":{"group_id":700272298,"message":[{"type":"text","data":{"text":"嘻嘻哥，这不就是你嘛～飞翔说\"妹妹我失眠了\"，想我睡不着就直说呗！"}}]},"echo":{"seq":630}}
[INFO] 发送 -> 群聊 [拾遗者(700272298)] [有曦(3642941266)] 嘻嘻哥，这不就是你嘛～飞翔说"妹妹我失眠了"，想我睡不着就直说呗！

[dosubot]

感谢提供 NapCat 端的调试日志。根据日志，NapCat 内部确实正确解析了转发消息中的所有 3 条节点（包括 bot 的消息）。问题很可能出在 NapCat 通过 OneBot API 返回 get_forward_msg 时，bot 自身消息节点的 message 字段为空或格式不符合预期。

从代码层面分析，AstrBot 在解析转发节点时的关键逻辑是 [1]：

raw_content = node.get("message") or node.get("content") or []
# ... 解析 segments ...
if node_text:
    texts.append(f"{indent}{sender_name}: {node_text}")

如果某个节点的 message/content 字段为空或解析后无文本内容，该节点会被静默跳过。 这就解释了为什么 bot 最终只看到了"飞翔: 妹妹我失眠了"这一条。

AstrBot 本身没有根据 sender_id 过滤转发节点的逻辑 [2]，所以这不是 AstrBot 故意忽略 bot 消息。

建议排查方向：

1. 在 AstrBot 中开启 DEBUG 日志，抓取 get_forward_msg 的实际返回 JSON，确认 bot 消息节点的 message 字段内容
2. 如果确认 NapCat 返回的 bot 消息节点 message 为空，那这是 NapCat 的问题——它可能在转发给外部时没有正确填充自己发送的消息内容
3. 可以尝试升级 NapCat 版本，或向 NapCat 提交 issue 反馈此问题

To reply, just mention @dosu.

---

Share context across your team and agents. Try Dosu.